Find out the real cost of metal roofing vs. asphalt shingles. We break down the higher upfront cost of metal against the massive long-term savings in energy, maintenance, and replacements. While asphalt shingles are more affordable upfront, metal roofs require a higher initial investment. Costs for both options are often compared on a per square foot basis. Metal roofs cost 2 to 3 times more upfront than asphalt shingles but last 2 to 3 times longer, making them a durable and cost-effective choice over time.
Introduction
When considering a roof replacement for your home in Metro Atlanta, the most common question we hear is: “Is a metal roof cheaper than shingles?” This article will focus on the key considerations in the metal roof vs shingles Georgia debate, helping you compare the two options for your specific needs.
The short answer is clear: No, a metal roof is significantly more expensive than an asphalt shingle roof upfront.
However, the longer answer is that metal roofing is often much cheaper over the lifetime of your home.
At Pro Roofing & Siding, we want to help you think like a long-term investor, not just a short-term buyer. We’ll break down the true cost comparison between the two most popular roofing materials, detailing how the initial investment in metal leads to substantial savings on energy bills, maintenance, and future replacements. Choosing the right roof for Georgia’s climate means considering durability, cost, and long-term value, so you can make the best decision in the metal roof vs shingles comparison.
1. The Upfront Cost Comparison
When comparing metal roofs vs shingles, the initial price is where asphalt shingles win, primarily because the materials are less expensive to manufacture and the installation requires less specialized labor and time. As traditional roofing materials, asphalt shingles have been the standard for affordability, and their lower installation costs make them an affordable choice for many homeowners. Metal roofs, on the other hand, can cost 40-50% more initially, which is a significant factor for budget-conscious buyers.
| Roofing System | Installed Cost Per Sq. Ft. (Avg. Range) | Total Investment Over 50 Years |
|---|---|---|
| Architectural Asphalt Shingles | $5.00 – $9.00 | Requires 2-3 replacements over 50 years. Total cost is higher. |
| Steel Metal Roofing (Standing Seam) | $8.00 – $16.00 | Metal roofs cost more per square foot than asphalt shingles, but require 1 installation over 50 years. Total cost is lower. |
Export to Sheets
Note: Costs vary based on labor, roof complexity, and specific metal type (e.g., copper can exceed $30 per sq. ft.).
Why Metal Costs More Initially:
- Material: Metal panels are more expensive than petroleum-based shingles.
- Labor: Installing a standing seam metal roof requires specialized skills, custom fabrication (cutting panels on-site), and takes more time than shingle installation, leading to higher labor rates.
- Components: Metal requires more specialized fasteners and meticulous flashing work.
2. The Long-Term Value (Where Metal Wins)
While the higher upfront cost of metal may be daunting, comparing metal roofs to other options helps many homeowners understand what each roofing material offers in terms of durability, cost-effectiveness, and long-term value. Many homeowners who choose less durable materials, such as asphalt shingles, often face frequent replacement and maintenance, leading to higher long-term costs despite their lower initial price. This makes metal roofs the clear financial winner for anyone planning to stay in their home for more than 15-20 years.
A. Durability and Longevity of Metal Roofing
- Asphalt Shingles: Lifespan is typically 15 to 30 years in the harsh Georgia climate (heat, hail, UV exposure). Traditional asphalt shingles often require more frequent replacement due to damage from intense summer heat and Georgia weather, leading to more frequent replacement needs. UV rays can also cause asphalt shingles to dry out and crack over time, further reducing their lifespan. You will likely replace your asphalt roof at least twice over 50 years.
- Metal Roofing: Lifespan is typically 40 to 70 years (and sometimes longer). Interlocking panels provide superior resistance to strong winds and extreme weather, reducing the need for a new roof. Metal roofs also offer excellent fire resistance, making them a highly durable and safe option. A metal roof is often the last roof you will ever buy, eliminating the cost of future tear-offs, labor, and materials.
B. Energy Efficiency and Savings of Metal Roofing
This is a critical factor in hot climates like Atlanta.
- Asphalt: Traditional dark shingles absorb massive amounts of solar heat, driving attic temperatures up to 150∘F, which transfers heat into your living space.
- Metal: Metal roofs, especially those with reflective coatings, are considered “Cool Roofs.” They reflect up to 70% of the sun’s rays, drastically lowering attic temperatures. Homeowners often report 10% to 25% savings on their summer cooling costs. Metal roofing can lead to energy savings of up to 40% due to its reflective properties, which help keep homes cooler. Metal roofs are more energy efficient compared to asphalt shingles, as their reflective properties and thermal characteristics help reduce energy costs. When combined with proper insulation, metal roofs can provide significant energy savings by maintaining cooler surface temperatures and improving indoor temperature control.
C. Maintenance and Repair Costs
- Asphalt: Requires more frequent maintenance, including replacing missing shingles, patching leaks, and cleaning mold/algae growth, especially as the roof ages.
- Metal: Known for its low maintenance requirements, especially when proper installation is performed. Metal is fire-resistant, impervious to pests, and highly resistant to cracking or losing its protective surface. Repairs are less frequent, though sometimes more complex if needed.
D. Increased Home Value
Metal roofs are a strong selling point. They can increase a home’s resale value and often recover a very high percentage of their installation cost (85% to 95%) at the time of sale. The compatibility of solar panels metal roofing and the modern look of sleek panels can further boost resale value, as these features appeal to buyers seeking energy efficiency and contemporary style. Metal roofs can increase home resale value by 4-6% due to their durability and energy efficiency. They also may qualify you for discounts on homeowner’s insurance due to their superior fire and wind resistance.
Environmental Impact: Sustainability and Eco-Friendliness
Metal roofing delivers real sustainability. Most metal roofs contain 90%+ recycled content. When they reach end-of-life after 50+ years, every piece gets recycled again. Zero landfill waste. Compare that to asphalt shingles—they dump millions of tons into landfills every single year. Metal roofs are often made from 25-95% recycled content, enhancing their sustainability profile. Metal roofing supports a true circular economy. Your investment pays environmental dividends for decades. Metal roofs also maximize solar panel efficiency with superior structural support and reflective properties. You generate more clean energy per square foot. For homeowners serious about environmental impact, metal roofing wins. It’s sustainable from manufacture to installation to eventual recycling.
Installation Process: What Homeowners Should Expect
Metal roofing installation differs from standard shingle work. Here’s what you need to know. Metal roofs demand specialized training and equipment. Each panel gets precisely measured, cut, and installed. This creates a seamless, watertight barrier. The process takes more time and costs more upfront. But here’s the payoff—you get exceptional durability and energy efficiency that metal roofs deliver. Smart contractors inspect your existing roof deck first. They assess your home’s structural integrity. This ensures your home can handle the new roofing material. Asphalt shingle roofs install faster and cheaper initially. But they need more frequent repairs and earlier replacement. Talk through the installation process with your contractor in detail. This helps you make an informed choice about which roofing material fits your needs and budget best.
Aesthetic Options: Style and Curb Appeal
Want better curb appeal? Both metal and shingle roofs deliver real aesthetic impact. Metal roofing gives you dozens of color choices, finishes, and profiles. Go sleek and modern. Or pick styles that look like wood or slate. Standing seam panels create bold, clean lines. Metal shingles offer classic appeal. Your pick depends on your home’s style. Modern architectural shingles work differently but just as well. They mimic wood shakes perfectly. They copy clay tile texture. They give you asphalt’s proven performance. Here’s what matters: how your roof fits your home’s exterior. How it matches neighborhood standards. How it reflects your taste. Pick right and you boost home value. You create lasting curb appeal that works for decades.
Regional Considerations: Climate and Local Factors
Your roof choice isn’t about looks or budget alone. It’s about performance in your local climate. Severe weather demands smart material decisions. Metal roofs outperform traditional shingles against heavy rain, high winds, and hail—no contest. Georgia’s brutal summers? Metal roofs reflect solar heat, cutting your cooling costs and keeping attics cooler. Cold-weather areas get another benefit: metal prevents ice dams that cause water damage. Don’t forget local building codes. They’ll shape your options whether you like it or not. Here’s the bottom line: talk to an experienced roofing contractor who knows your area. They’ll guide you through climate factors and regulations, ensuring you choose materials that deliver long-term durability and real peace of mind.
The Lifetime Cost Comparison
Let’s look at a hypothetical 50-year cost for a home requiring a 25-square roof:
| Factor | Asphalt Shingle (3 Replacements) | Metal Roof (1 Installation) |
|---|---|---|
| Initial Cost (Year 0) | $10,000 | $20,000 |
| Replacement 1 (Year 20) | $12,000 (with inflation) | $0 |
| Replacement 2 (Year 40) | $15,000 (with inflation) | $0 |
| 50-Year Cost (No Energy Savings) | $37,000 | $20,000 |
| Energy Savings (50 Years) | $0 | Significant Savings |
Export to Sheets
Conclusion: Over 50 years, the total cost of an asphalt roof is nearly double that of a single, well-installed metal roof. When comparing metal roofs cost vs asphalt roofs over 50 years, the roof vs analysis clearly favors metal for long-term savings, especially considering the frequent replacement required for asphalt roofs.
Conclusion + Call-to-Action
When asking, “Is a metal roof cheaper than shingles?” the answer depends on your timeline. If you plan to sell your home within five years, asphalt is cheaper. If you plan to stay in your home for decades or view your roof as a permanent asset, metal roofing is the superior financial investment. It protects your home better, saves you money on cooling, and eliminates future replacement costs.
For a free, no-obligation estimate on the best roofing material for your home’s unique needs and budget, trust the local experts.
Call Pro Roofing & Siding today at (770) 777-1733 to compare the upfront cost of asphalt with the long-term value of metal, or visit www.myproroofing.com to schedule your consultation! For more information about our Marietta roofing contractor services, contact us today.
